source file: mills3.txt Date: Wed, 30 Jul 1997 00:59:03 +0200 Subject: Re:Ernest McClain From: gagaku@cats.ucsc.edu (Fred Lieberman) On 7/28/97, "George Kahrimanis" inquired about the work of Ernest McClain. In my opinion, McClain is one of the most stimulating and original thinkers in his field. (He may also be the =only= thinker in his field.) =The Pythagorean Plato= is probably much easier to understand if read after his first book, =The Myth of Invariance=, in which he sets forth many of the principles and theories that are later elaborated and applied to Plato. Much of his work rests on certain axioms or assumptions about the nature of early scientific thought, both conceptual and practical, that must be grokked before the whole edifice can stand on its own. Some folks reject the assumptions; I find them intriguing and full of rich consequences. An important influence, almost a prolegemena to McClain's work, is =Hamlet's Mill: an Essay Investigating the Origins of Human Knowledge and its Transmission through Myth= by Giorgio de Santillana and Hertha von Dechend (1969; Godine pb 1977; other reprints available). McClain's articles on Chinese and Sumerian/Babylonian scale theory (not yet published in book form) expand significantly on his ideas, and if anything make them more convincing and clear. If there is interest, I would be willing to compile a bibliography of his work, though if someone out there already has one, please post it to the list. McClain is retired and elderly (78), sharp as a whip and a complete gentleman of the old school. Open to discussion and debate, he welcomes serious correspondence; I do not believe he has access to e-mail. His address is: Dr. Ernest G. McClain Box 192 Belmont, VT 05730