This page may be out of date. Submit any pending changes before refreshing this page.
Hide this message.
Quora uses cookies to improve your experience. Read more
Robert Walker
No, not at all. Sam is in love with Rosie, who he marries after he gets back from his quest. And as for Frodo - he's just leading a solitary life.

The idea that everyone has to be in a relationship or get married or if not they are asexual or gay - that's quite a modern idea I think. Nowadays it can often seem as if you have to do that to prove that you are heterosexual, even, which I think is a crazy thing.  This idea that some people have that you have to be in a relationship and if not, you should get into one as soon as you possibly can almost, and that if you don't do that you are surely asexual...

Maybe you've never met the right person.

Or maybe you are like Patrick Moore whose first love died in the war before they got married, and he never wanted to marry anyone else.

Or like a monk, some people take vows of celibacy. Or others while not taking formal vows, their direction of life leads to celibacy in the way they behave for one reason or another, not meaning at all that they are asexual. Perhaps in an open ended way that would change if circumstances changed.

Also - like in modern fiction and romantic movies, it's often presented as if getting married solves all your problems and you "live happily ever after" which of course is not true at all and if you are sensible you just take that as a fun movie convention, and don't take it too seriously - but I think it sometimes leads some people in modern society to unrealistic expectations and divorce and trying to remarry and find the "right person" to solve all your problems which will never work out.

I think back then was less of that idea also that it would solve all your problems.

So as for Frodo and Bilbo, there's no explanation of why they are single. Maybe they never met the right person.

It's worth noting that Frodo's parents died when he was only twelve years old in a boating accident. Which might well be something of a disincentive to get married himself, who knows.

They are just two friends who know each other well, and have gone through a lot together, and who care for each other.
 
And in this case, a particularly close bond - they have been through terrible times together, and have saved each other's lives many times also.

They started up as master and his servant, but gradually Frodo came to realize that Sam had a natural wisdom and fortitude and depth of understanding that he never realized he had when he was just his gardener at Bag End and Sam also came to appreciate qualities of Frodo that he'd never have realized if he had just gone on gardening for him in hobbiton when he would just be the posh and rather nice gentleman hobbit who he did the garden for and his father did the garden for before, and who had a shared interest in elves.

A lot of the interest in the story is in this developing appreciation of the various characters for each other.

This is based on the book rather than the films. I've watched some parts of some of the films but not yet watched any of them all the way through I think. They depart quite a bit from the story. So, film may be different but in the books, all there is are scenes that show they care for each other, e.g. Sam seldom far from Frodo's bedside when he is recovering in Rivendell, etc.

About the Author

Robert Walker

Robert Walker

Writer of articles on Mars and Space issues - Software Developer of Tune Smithy, Bounce Metronome etc.
Studied at Wolfson College, Oxford
Lives in Isle of Mull
4.8m answer views110.3k this month
Top Writer2017, 2016, and 2015
Published WriterHuffPost, Slate, and 4 more